Joseph Gerard Cancellare Arrested After Mailing Peanut Butter-Coated Card to Allergic Woman

Date:


Joseph Gerard Cancellare, 68, was arrested in Florida after investigators alleged he mailed a peanut-butter-smeared card to a woman with a severe allergy. (Foto: Instagram)

Joseph Gerard Cancellare, 68, was arrested in Florida after allegedly mailing a card smeared with peanut butter to his ex-wife’s best friend, who has a severe allergy to the food. Investigators said Cancellare blamed the woman for contributing to his divorce and allegedly knew the peanut butter could kill her or seriously injure her.

The card was sent in August 2025, according to investigators. The recipient, whose identity has not been disclosed, told authorities she found an envelope near the entrance to her driveway. It appeared to be stained with a brown, greasy substance. Inside was a handwritten greeting card. Although she did not recognize the handwriting, she identified the substance as peanut butter, dropped the envelope and ran inside to wash her hands.

The woman told investigators that she soon developed hives and tingling in both arms, symptoms that lasted about six hours, according to local media reports. Authorities said Cancellare had tried to make the mailing appear official, using a false sender name and return address, along with a stamp and postmark. Investigators traced the stamp’s purchase to Cancellare’s home. A kiosk where he bought it had taken his photograph about a week before the card was mailed, allowing the woman to recognize him.

The recipient said she and Cancellare had last spoken about three years earlier, at a meeting related to the divorce settlement. She recalled that he made several comments expressing a desire to harm people connected to the separation. Cancellare was arrested on Nov. 13, 2026, and charged with aggravated assault with a deadly weapon and culpable negligence for exposing another person to harm.

Share post:

Popular

More like this
Related