Brazil Seeks WTO Dispute Panel to Review U.S. Tariffs on Brazilian Goods

Date:


Brazil has asked the World Trade Organization to establish a panel reviewing U.S. tariffs on Brazilian products after bilateral talks failed to resolve the dispute. (Foto: Instagram)

Brazil has asked the World Trade Organization to establish a dispute panel to review U.S. tariffs on Brazilian products, after consultations between the two countries failed to produce an agreement. The request was filed on Nov. 12 by the government of President Luiz Inácio Lula da Silva and seeks to move the case into the WTO’s formal dispute-resolution process.

The filing follows consultations Brazil initiated in July. Brazilian and U.S. diplomats met at the WTO headquarters in Geneva, Switzerland, on Sept. 25 to try to reach a negotiated settlement before a panel was established. The talks did not resolve the dispute. In its request, Brazil said the consultations were intended to find a mutually acceptable solution but had not succeeded.

Brazil contests U.S. tariffs imposed under Section 301, specifically rates of 25% and 12.5%. The filing argues that Washington violated international trade rules by taking unilateral measures against Brazil. Those are claims made by the Brazilian government; the WTO panel would assess the dispute rather than treat the allegations as established.

Establishing a panel would not automatically suspend the tariffs. It would begin a review of whether the measures comply with trade rules and whether they harmed Brazil’s production chain. The WTO could also determine whether Brazil has the right to take retaliatory action, depending on the outcome of the process.

Brazilian diplomats have low expectations that the case will lead to an effective resolution of the tariff dispute, according to published information. They view bringing the matter before the WTO in part as a procedural step that formally records Brazil’s opposition to the tariff rates. The article cites the WTO cotton dispute, in which Brazil prevailed against the United States, as a previous case, but diplomats do not expect the current panel to produce a comparable result.

The prospects are also constrained by the WTO dispute system’s paralysis since December 2019. The administration of President Donald Trump began blocking appointments of judges to the body’s appellate division, the final level of review for trade disputes. The WTO continues to receive complaints and hold consultations, but the source says it is unable to adjudicate cases or take effective action in disputes.

Share post:

Popular

More like this
Related

UN Court Finds Myanmar Responsible for Genocide Against Rohingya

The International Court of Justice...

Police Operation in Haiti Leaves 34 Dead, Police Say

A police operation in Port-au-Prince,...

Reinaldo Dennes’ Texas Execution Lasts More Than an Hour as He Reports Pain

Reinaldo Dennes was executed in...

Trump, Putin and Xi Meeting Raises Concerns Over U.S. Alliances and Global Security

U.S. President Donald Trump, Russian...